In partnership with

Yes, that Arnold Schwarzenegger.

He has a newsletter on beehiiv. So do Codie Sanchez, Jay Shetty, David Begnaud, Colin & Samir, and Joanna Stern.

They could publish just about anywhere. They chose beehiiv to build a direct connection with the people who want to hear from them most. And you can do the same, whether you’re world-famous or just at the start of your plan for world domination.

Get started for free.

If you've got a shoebox of cards waiting for PSA's cheap grading tiers to come back, you've been waiting since June. The good news is that the line is finally getting shorter, and fast. The less obvious news is that when the floodgates reopen, not everyone comes out ahead.

How we got here

On June 2, 2026, PSA paused all of its Value tiers. The company said a roughly 20% spike in submissions had pushed its backlog toward 10 million items. Alongside the pause, it launched a public Backlog Tracker and pointed to a $200 million investment in capacity. PSA also set a clear goal: bring the backlog down to 5 million units. It said reopening would be tied "strictly to operational milestones, not arbitrary dates."

The pause didn't stop the pile from growing right away. According to PSA's own updates, the backlog sat around 12 million at the end of June, dipped to 11 million in mid-July, then jumped to 12.4 million by July 28. PSA blamed higher-tier submissions, a wave of late shipments from before the shutdown, and convention season.

The comeback in numbers

Since that late-July peak, the tracker has fallen every two weeks:

• August 11: 11.85 million

• August 25: about 10.9 million

• September 8: 9.9 million

• September 22: about 9 million

• October 6: 8.2 million

That's roughly a third of the pile cleared in about ten weeks (PSA). New capacity helped. PSA opened a grading hub in Plano, Texas in the summer and a Frankfurt facility in September, and it now cites six global hubs. In its October 6 update, PSA said the current pace "puts us on path to assess reopening additional service tiers in the coming months."

Output is up sharply too. According to GemRate data cited by Burke & Stock, PSA graded about 2.46 million cards in September, up 12% from August. GemRate's figures, also via Burke & Stock, show CGC graded roughly 962,000, up 3%.

What's open right now

PSA's cheapest available option is the Standard tier, launched September 14 at $59.99 per card with an estimated 90 to 100 business-day turnaround (Burke & Stock). One important catch from PSA's own tracker: new Standard orders are queued behind the Value and Bulk orders already in the building from before the pause.

Competitors are working the gap. CGC is running 20% off CrossOver regrades through October 31, and TAG and SGC have their own discounts, per CardBiz's October deals roundup.

So when does Value come back?

PSA hasn't given a date, and it's been explicit that it won't. Burke & Stock did some back-of-the-envelope math. If the backlog keeps dropping 800,000 to 1 million cards every two weeks, it would hit 5 million around late November to mid-December. That's their projection, not PSA's, and PSA hasn't promised that hitting 5 million automatically reopens Value.

Who wins and who gets hurt

This is where it gets interesting for anyone buying or selling slabs. The following is our analysis, not a forecast:

• Collectors with low-value raw cards: You're the clear winners. If a card isn't worth the $59.99 Standard fee, waiting for Value still makes sense.

• Holders of modern PSA 10s: Value grading reopening would mean a supply surge. Millions of cards graded faster means more gem-mint copies of popular modern cards hitting marketplaces.

• Flippers: If you're sitting on modern slabs bought during the scarcity, consider whether today's prices reflect a temporarily choked supply.

• Vintage and high-end owners: Mostly insulated. Truly scarce cards don't gain meaningful new supply just because grading gets cheaper.

What to watch next

• PSA's next biweekly tracker update, expected around October 20 if the two-week rhythm holds. Another drop of 800,000 or more would keep the late-2026 timeline alive.

• Any official word on which tier reopens first. PSA has said "additional service tiers," not specifically Value.

• Modern PSA 10 prices. If they start softening before Value even returns, the market is already pricing in the coming supply.

• October 31: CGC's crossover discount expires.

Bottom line: the line is moving. Plan your submissions around the value of each card, not around a date nobody has promised.

Get every story first: download Nerdcave77 on the App Store.