In partnership with

Yes, that Arnold Schwarzenegger.

He has a newsletter on beehiiv. So do Codie Sanchez, Jay Shetty, David Begnaud, Colin & Samir, and Joanna Stern.

They could publish just about anywhere. They chose beehiiv to build a direct connection with the people who want to hear from them most. And you can do the same, whether you’re world-famous or just at the start of your plan for world domination.

Get started for free.

Three Pokémon cards cleared a million dollars in the span of four days this month. Two of them did it on the same Thursday. If you've ever wondered whether the vintage Pokémon market had a ceiling, early October suggests we haven't found it yet. It also offers a few warnings worth reading before you price your own binder off a headline.

The four days that rewrote the record book

It started on Thursday, October 8, at Alt. A 1st Edition Neo Genesis Typhlosion in PSA 10 sold for $1,549,690, according to TCGCharts. To put that in perspective, the previous record for the same card was $415,500, set just this June. Only 13 PSA 10 copies are known to exist, and one buyer decided this one was worth nearly four times the old high.

Hours later, the card everyone knows had its turn. A 1st Edition Base Set Charizard in PSA 10 closed at $1,385,274 after 46 bids. That's the highest public price ever paid for one, topping the $954,800 a copy brought at Goldin in February (TCGCharts). Jazwares president and longtime collector Jeremy Padawer, who first broke the price on X, wrote: "20X return in 7 years. Wow. Blown away."

Then on Sunday, October 11, an Art Academy "Raincoat" Pikachu, a 2015 Japanese promo featuring art by Y. Fujishima, sold in PSA 10 for $1,037,000 on October 11 (Otia). The sale happened at Goldin after 64 bids (TCGCharts).

Some context: where these sit in hobby history

None of these touch the all-time mark. The most ever paid for a trading card is still $16,492,000 for a PSA 10 Pikachu Illustrator at Goldin in February 2026, per The Card Shop Finder's running list. But the October sales matter for a different reason. Two of them come from real, widely collected sets (Neo Genesis and Base Set), and that makes them benchmarks for thousands of collectors.

The rally also isn't confined to the headliners. TCGCharts data shows the median pre-2011 PSA 10 card rose 36.7% over the last 30 days compared with the prior 60, with 90% of 307 pre-2011 cards higher. Modern cards (2011 and later) went the other way, with the median PSA 10 down 7.3%. Legendary Collection reverse holos roughly doubled at the median, and e-Card holos from Expedition, Aquapolis and Skyridge more than doubled (TCGCharts).

The Art Academy wrinkle

Here's where it gets weird. The same Raincoat Pikachu, in the same PSA 10 grade, reportedly hammered for $8.4 million at Fanatics Collect on September 27, two weeks before the $1.037 million Goldin sale (TCGCharts). Same card, same grade, a seven-million-dollar gap. When only a few dozen copies of a card exist, there's no real "market price," just whatever one determined buyer pays on one night.

A note of caution: was it actually paid?

The biggest cautionary tale of the month is about payment, not price. TCGCharts tracked Fanatics Collect's October 11 weekly auction, which closed with $30.6 million bid across 12,346 lots. By Friday, only about $5.3 million of that, roughly 17%, had been paid. Several eye-popping hammers from that night are still unconfirmed. Fanatics Collect began requiring a credit card on file to bid as of October 14.

That's why we're sticking to the reported Alt and Goldin results in this story and leaving out some other huge numbers that have been floating around social media.

One more caveat: payment on the October 8 Alt sales (the Typhlosion and the Charizard) hasn't been independently confirmed, according to Cardboard Signal and GempireCards.

What it means for collectors and flippers

• Vintage holders: This is the strongest bid the market has shown this year. If you've been waiting for a moment to sell a low-population vintage card, this may be it.

• Buyers: Don't chase records. A single sale resets the perceived value of every copy at once, and thin populations mean prices can swing hard in both directions.

• Flippers: Check whether a "comp" was actually paid before you price off it. An unpaid hammer is not a sale.

• Modern collectors: PSA's shrinking backlog means more modern slabs are coming to market, not fewer. Supply like that tends to cap prices.

What to watch next

• October 25: Goldin's 30th Anniversary auction closes, led by a 1997 Gold 1st Place Trophy Pikachu in PSA 8 that was bid to $2,225,000 as of October 10 (TCGCharts).

• October 29: Logan Paul plans to open sealed 2002 Legendary Collection boxes on stream, the same set whose reverse holos just doubled (TCGCharts).

• November 6: The Mega Evolution: Delta Reign expansion arrives (TCGCharts).

• Payment rates: Watch whether Fanatics Collect's new card-on-file rule shrinks the unpaid lots. That will tell us a lot about how real the frothiest numbers are.

Our take (speculation, clearly labeled): This looks more like money rotating out of modern and into scarce vintage than a market-wide boom. Enjoy the ride, but price with paid sales only.

Get every story first: download Nerdcave77 on the App Store.